Introduction
Public debt refers to the amount of money that a government borrows to finance its spending when tax revenues are not sufficient. It is one of the most important sources of funds to finance the development plans. A government can incur debt through various means. This includes borrowing from domestic or foreign sources, issuing bonds, or by printing money. However, if the debt burden becomes too high, it can lead to a number of problems such as high inflation, currency devaluation, and a decrease in economic growth.
Public debt sustainability refers to the ability of a government to meet its debt obligations without having to resort to measures that would harm the economy or the welfare of its citizens. It is a measure of the long-term solvency of a government and its ability to meet its debt obligations without harming the economy.
Public Debt Sustainability is the ability of a government to service its debt by paying the interest and principal payments due, without compromising its ability to invest. Public debt sustainability is important because high levels of debt can make it difficult for a government to borrow in the future or cause creditors to demand higher interest rates, which can negatively impact the government’s ability to invest in education, health care, infrastructure, and social welfare.
In order to understand public debt sustainability, it’s important to first understand what public debt is. To ensure public debt sustainability, governments need to ensure that the debt is used to finance productive investments that will generate economic growth and revenue to service the debt. Additionally, they need to have a plan in place to manage the debt and ensure that it does not become too large relative to the size of the economy or the government’s ability to generate revenue.
Factors Affecting Public Debt Sustainability
Economic Growth
By raising tax revenues and making debt servicing simpler, economic growth can help lessen the overall burden of governmental debt. On the other hand, sluggish economic growth can make debt servicing more challenging and result in a spiraling increase in debt loads.
Interest Rates
A government’s capacity to service its debt can be significantly impacted by the interest rates it pays on its debt. Low interest rates can make servicing debt simpler. It also enables governments to borrow more money, but high interest rates can make servicing debt difficult.
Fiscal Policies
Government expenditure and taxation, among other fiscal policies, can significantly affect the sustainability of the national debt. While low levels of spending and high rates of taxation can aid in debt reduction. Similarly, high levels of spending and low rates of taxation can cause debt levels to rise.
Demographics
Aging populations and other demographic trends can affect the sustainability of the public debt by raising the costs of social security and health care. Demographic with older generation has less contribution to GDP leading to high public debt and vice versa. The high demographics of older generation has been one of the reason for Japanese economy to have higher debt to GDP ratio.
Political Stability
Political stability can affect the ability of a government to enact laws that support fiscal restraint and prudent debt management, which can have an impact on the sustainability of the public debt.
Governments must carefully balance their spending and income strategies, try to foster economic growth, and take into account long-term demographic and political trends in order to achieve public debt sustainability. In order to ensure long-term sustainability, governments may also need to employ debt management measures including debt restructuring, debt forgiveness, or debt reduction through inflation or currency devaluation.
Measuring Public Debt Sustainability
There are several ways to measure public debt sustainability. Measuring public debt is necessary as it provides insight regarding the fiscal condition of a country.
Debt to GDP Ratio
One common approach to measure sustainability is the ratio of debt to GDP. It calculates the total amount of public debt as a percentage of the country’s GDP (Gross Domestic Product). This ratio provides a general indication of a country’s debt burden relative to its economic output. It is calculated by dividing a country’s total debt by its GDP and expressing the result as a percentage
A high Debt-to-GDP ratio can indicate a higher risk of default, as the government may not have enough revenue to service its debt. A country’s debt is large relative to its economic output and may indicate that the country has difficulty in servicing its debt obligations. The high value of this ration also suggests the default risk for a country which can lead to financial repercussions. A low debt to GDP ratio suggests that a country’s debt is small relative to its economic output and may indicate that the country has a low risk of defaulting on its debt obligations.
In general, a debt to GDP ratio below 60% is considered to be relatively low and manageable, while a ratio above 90% may be considered high and may raise concerns about a country’s ability to service its debt. However, the appropriate level of the ratio may vary depending on the country’s specific economic circumstances and its ability to generate revenue and manage its debt. Generally, the higher the debt-to-GDP ratio, the greater the risk of debt sustainability problems.
However, this ratio alone does not take into account the country’s growth rate, its interest rate, or its ability to generate revenue through taxation.
Countries and their Debt-GDP ratio
| Country | Debt/GDP Ratio (2023) |
| Japan | 237.00% |
| Greece | 177.00% |
| United States | 107.00% |
| Canada | 89.70% |
| United Kingdom | 80.70% |
| India | 69.62% |
| China | 50.50% |
| Afghanistan | 7.10% |
| Brunei | 2.40 % |
Debt Service to Revenue Ratio
Another way to measure public debt sustainability is to look at the debt service-to-revenue ratio. This ratio measures the government’s ability to service its debt by looking at the percentage of government revenue that goes towards debt service. A high ratio indicates that a large portion of the government’s revenue is being used to service its debt, which can be a sign of a high risk of default.
Primary Balance
The primary balance is the difference between government revenues and expenditures, excluding interest payments on debt. This measure focuses on whether the government is generating enough revenue to cover its current expenses, excluding the cost of servicing its debt. If a government has a positive primary balance, it means it is generating enough revenue to cover its expenses and can allocate funds to pay down its debt.
Interest Rate on Government Debt
Another way to measure public debt sustainability is to look at the interest rate on government debt. A high interest rate can indicate a higher risk of default, as the government may not be able to afford to pay the interest on its debt.
External Debt-to-Export Ratio
This measures a country’s external debt (debt owed to foreign creditors) as a percentage of its exports. This measure is used to assess a country’s ability to service its external debt. It is calculated by dividing a country’s total external debt by its total exports. The external debt represents the amount of money that a country owes to foreign creditors, including governments, international organizations, and private lenders. Exports, on the other hand, refer to the goods and services that a country sells to other countries.
A high external debt to exports ratio indicates that a country may have difficulties in repaying its debt if its exports earnings decline or if the cost of servicing the debt increases. It also suggests that a large portion of a country’s export earnings is being used to pay off its external debt, which may limit its ability to invest in other areas such as education, healthcare, and infrastructure.
On the other hand, a low external debt to exports ratio suggests that a country has a strong export base and is less vulnerable to external economic shocks. It also indicates that a country has more resources available to invest in its development. In general, a healthy external debt to exports ratio is considered to be below 100%. However, the appropriate level of the ratio may vary depending on a country’s specific economic circumstances and its ability to generate export earnings.
Other Measures
Additionally, experts take into account the country’s economic situation, growth rate, and revenue generating capacity to check the Public debt sustainability. It is important to note that no single measure can fully capture public debt sustainability, and a comprehensive assessment should take into account multiple indicators and factors. Additionally, government’s policies on fiscal responsibility, transparency, inflation targeting, and maintaining a healthy balance of trade also play an important role in ensuring public debt sustainability.
Sustainable Level of Public Debt
The sustainable level of public debt for a country is the level at which the government can continue to service its debt without causing harm to the economy or the welfare of its citizens. It is not a fixed number and can vary depending on the country’s economic situation, growth rate, and revenue generating capacity. Achieving a sustainable level of public debt requires a combination of responsible fiscal policies, effective debt management, and a strong economy.
Illustration
Japan has the highest ratio for Debt to GDP, yet it is one of the most developed economies. Japan’s higher ratio of debt to GDP is complemented by strong fiscal policies, planned investment and support from the central authorities of the country.
Fiscal policies such as maintaining a balanced budget, keeping spending under control, and increasing revenue through taxation can help keep the debt-to-GDP ratio at a sustainable level. Additionally, debt management strategies such as diversifying the sources of debt and lengthening the maturity of debt can help to reduce the risk of default.
A strong and growing economy is also essential for public debt sustainability. A high GDP growth rate can help to reduce the debt-to-GDP ratio and increase the government’s ability to generate revenue to service the debt. Additionally, a healthy balance of trade will help to ensure that the country is not over-reliant on borrowing from foreign sources.
In order to achieve a sustainable level of public debt, countries also need to maintain financial sector stability, adopt inflation targeting policies, and maintain a flexible exchange rate.
Achieving Sustainable Level
Achieving a sustainable level of public debt involves a combination of prudent fiscal policy, responsible debt management, and economic growth. Here are some ways in which countries can achieve a sustainable level of public debt:
Prudent Fiscal Policy
Governments must carefully manage their spending and revenue policies to ensure that they maintain a balanced budget, or at least a manageable level of deficits. Governments must focus on reducing wasteful spending and promoting efficient use of resources, while ensuring that essential services and infrastructure investments are adequately funded. Raising taxes and cutting spending are two ways to reduce debt, but should be done in a manner that does not undermine the economy or the welfare of citizens.
Responsible Debt Management
Governments must also focus on responsible borrowing, by ensuring that their debt is diversified and long-term, minimizing currency and interest rate risks, and monitoring debt sustainability metrics. Governments must work to secure affordable interest rates and negotiate favorable repayment terms, which can help reduce the burden of debt. Debt management policies, such as debt restructuring, debt forgiveness, or debt reduction through inflation or currency devaluation, may also be necessary.
Economic Growth
A growing economy can help to reduce the burden of public debt, as it generates more revenue through taxes and leads to higher employment levels. Governments must focus on policies that promote economic growth, such as investing in infrastructure, education, and innovation. A growing economy can also lead to higher levels of inflation, which can reduce the real value of the debt over time.
Demographic Factors
As populations age and demands on social safety nets and health care increase, governments must carefully consider their long-term obligations and their ability to fund them. This means being proactive in making necessary adjustments to social security and pension programs, and finding ways to reduce the cost of health care.
In conclusion, achieving a sustainable level of public debt requires a combination of responsible borrowing, prudent fiscal policy, and economic growth. The exact level of sustainable public debt will vary from country to country, but governments must focus on keeping their debt manageable and investing in the essential services and infrastructure that will support their long-term prosperity.
Public Debt and Private Investment
Public debt and private investment are negatively correlated. Higher public debt pushes the interest rate up and affects private investment. To have a sustainable level of public debt, private investment needs to be encouraged. Private sector involvement in different development projects lower the burden of debt requirements from the government.
It’s important to note that achieving a sustainable level of public debt is a continuous process that requires constant monitoring and adjustments to fiscal and debt management policies. Additionally, external factors such as global economic conditions and natural disasters can also affect a country’s ability to sustain its public debt.
References